Websites AI search can find · Birmingham, Michigan

← All articles

We Reviewed 100+ Local Business Websites. The Same 9 Problems Kept Showing Up

Published November 21, 2026

By Stephen Yatooma

Florist at her shop counter checking orders on a phone and laptop

The short answer: most small business websites aren’t broken. They’re just missing a handful of small things that help Google, AI search tools and real customers understand them. In November we looked at more than 100 local business websites around Metro Detroit, from restaurants and therapists to title companies and driving schools. We flagged 28 of them as having the most room to improve, and the same problems showed up on site after site.

Here’s what we found, how often it came up among those 28 sites, and what to do about each one. We’re not naming anyone. Every one of these sites belongs to a real business doing good work, and most of these fixes take minutes, not a rebuild.

1. Photos with no alt text (23 of 28 sites)

This was the most common problem by far. Alt text is a short written description attached to an image. Screen readers read it aloud to people who can’t see the photo, and Google uses it to understand what the image shows. One home page we checked had 78 images and 48 of them had no description at all. Missing alt text is also one of the most common items in ADA website complaints. Read more about alt text and form labels.

2. A confusing heading structure (15 of 28)

Every page should have one main heading (an H1) that says what the page is about, with smaller subheadings underneath. Some sites had none. One had 18. Clear headings help screen reader users move around the page and help search engines and AI tools pick out the topic. Here’s how headings work.

3. A phone number you can’t tap (10 of 28)

Most visitors to a local business site are on a phone. If the number is plain text, they have to copy it by hand. Making it a tap-to-call link is a one-line fix. More on tap-to-call and other mobile basics.

4. A page title that says “Home” (9 of 28)

The page title is the blue headline Google shows in search results and the text on the browser tab. We saw titles like “Home,” “Home | My Site 1” (a website builder’s placeholder) and “Welcome to” followed by the business name. None of those tell Google, or a customer, what you do or where. How to write a better page title.

5. No meta description (9 of 28)

The meta description is the short summary that often appears under your title in Google. Without one, Google grabs whatever text it finds, which might be a cookie notice or a menu. Writing your own takes five minutes and gives you a better shot at the click.

6. Slow pages (6 of 28)

Six sites took six seconds or more to load. One took close to 20. Usually the cause is huge photos straight off a camera or phone. Why speed matters and how to fix it.

7. Very little text on the home page (6 of 28)

Several home pages had fewer than 250 words. Google and AI search tools need words to understand what you offer, who you serve and where. A few short sections can make a real difference. How much text a home page needs.

8. Form fields with no labels (6 of 28)

Contact and sign-up forms where the boxes have no labels, or only gray placeholder text that disappears when you type, are hard to use for everyone and nearly impossible with a screen reader. The alt text post covers this too.

9. Small trust signals: Gmail addresses and old copyright dates (10 of 28)

Six sites listed a Gmail, AOL or similar address as the main contact, and four had a footer copyright from 2016 to 2024. Neither breaks anything, but both make a business look smaller or less active than it is. Small trust signals that add up.

What was working

It wasn’t all bad news. Plenty of sites loaded in about a second, were secure (https), and had real, useful content. A few were simply excellent. The pattern we saw is that a site gets built, launches, and then nobody looks at it again for a few years. Small issues pile up quietly.

How to check your own site in 10 minutes

  1. Google your business name and look at the title and description that show up.
  2. Open your site on your phone and try to call yourself with one tap.
  3. Look at your footer. Is the year current? Is the email on your own domain?
  4. Run your home page through a free tool like our ADA website checker to see missing alt text and form labels.
  5. Try our AI Search Readiness Score to see how ChatGPT and Google’s AI answers might read your site.

Want a second set of eyes on your site? Run it through our free ADA website checker or AI Search Readiness Score, or send us your web address and we’ll tell you what we see. No pressure and no jargon.

Frequently asked questions

What is the most common problem on small business websites?

In our review, missing alt text on images was the most common, showing up on 23 of the 28 sites we flagged. It’s also one of the easiest to fix.

Do I need a new website to fix these problems?

Usually not. Almost everything on this list can be fixed on the site you already have, often in an afternoon.

How often should I check my website?

A quick look every few months is enough for most small businesses. If you add new photos or pages, check alt text and headings as you go.

← Back to all articles